Welcome

Atlantic Seafood Market

Old Saybrook Conn.

View MenuAbout us

Voted Business of the Year by Old Saybrook Chamber of Commerce

We were featured in

Learn More

Yankee Magazine Weighs in on Atlantic Seafood Market

“This market is the seafood gem of the lower Connecticut River valley. Owned by Lisa Feinman, everything here is as fresh as it can be. CIA-trained resident chef Jerry Doran and his staff cut all their fish fresh and make all their prepared seafood delights from scratch every day. Late spring is a good time to pay a visit, when the shad are running up the Connecticut River and fresh shad and shad roe are in plentiful supply.”

Learn More

Zagat Review

“Incredibly wonderful seafood. Order all your fresh and frozen fish from them. Known for their cocktail shrimp. It does not get better than this. This is definitely the place to go when you are entertaining and want the very best.” -Susan Monday, Zagat

Learn More

Nationally syndicated newspaper USA Today recently published an article about local seafood markets and the special perks customers are treated to when visiting them. Locally sourced seafood, in-depth knowledge about products and their benefits, and unbeatable freshness are all points that this article touched upon.

Sustainable food & practices as well as having the best fitting seafood for every season are additional reasons why local, independent seafood markets give you something that the big chains just can’t match. We’re humbled to have been featured in this article along with some of the other best seafood markets in America.

We offer

Our Seafood

We’re obsessed with finding the highest-quality, freshest, and most delicious local seafood that the ocean has to offer. We’re proud to be able to say that you’ll never find a drop of artificial color, pesticides, preservatives, or growth hormones in any of our products. We’re fully committed to supplying our customers with the freshest, healthiest, and most natural seafood in Connecticut.

Salads

All dishes are prepared without preservatives and are made from scratch daily (even our salad dressings!). Choose from our broad collection of seafood salads, featuring such items as CT lobster salad, crab salad, dill shrimp salad, and more. If you have a landlubber to feed, don’t worry, because we have several non-seafood salads as well, such as our exotic Wild Rice and Mandarin Orange salad, Red Cabbage and Carrot Salad, and many more which make for a delicious vegetarian dinner.

Prepared Meals

All our prepared seafood dishes (main dishes, sides & appetizers, soups, salads) are proudly made from scratch daily at Atlantic Seafood, Connecticut’s best seafood market. Whether you’re looking for creamy New England Clam Chowder, Manhattan Clam Chowder, Lobster Salad, or any other gourmet seafood treat, our prepared dishes are sure to satisfy the whole family.

Soups

All dishes are prepared from scratch daily. We serve every seafood soup you can think of, and then some. If you’re in the mood for that quintessential New England seafood classic New England Clam Chowder, a lighter Rhode Island Clear Broth Chowder, Manhattan Clam Chowder, Corn Chowder, Lobster Bisque featuring the best lobster in CT, or any other delicious seafood soup, we have you covered. Come on down to our Old Saybrook, Connecticut seafood market and try one our soups today!

Who we are?

Located on the Boston Post Road in Old Saybrook, Connecticut,  Atlantic Seafood Market has been serving customers since 1978.

Our seafood is so fresh…well, here’s how Christopher Brooks of the New York Times put it:
“To find fish any fresher, you’d probably have to throw out a line and catch them yourself.”

We’re obsessive about finding the highest-quality, freshest, and most local seafood.

Read More

Prepared Meals

All our prepared seafood dishes (main dishes, sides & appetizers, soups, salads) are proudly made from scratch daily by Chef Jerry, a graduate of the Culinary Institute of America in New York who has worked in 5-star, high-volume restaurants for more than 25 years who now renders his services to Atlantic Seafood, Connecticut’s best seafood market. Whether you’re looking for creamy New England Clam Chowder, Manhattan Clam Chowder, Lobster Salad, or any other gourmet seafood treat, our prepared dishes are sure to satisfy the whole family.

Home Delivery

We are happy to now offer Home Delivery. Please note there is a surcharge to facilitate delivery. It is reflected in the price per item. Please note you can also order for pick up, there is a small fee to order online. To receive our best price please call us (860) 388-4527

Order Now

Join our Email List

Subscribe

* indicates required



/

( mm / dd )


We offer Gift Cards

Looking for a gift for that hard to shop for person, come on in and grab a gift card!

Testimonials

 While our awards from famous food critiquing institutions have time and again shown us to have the best seafood in CT,our Old Saybrook, CT seafood market has won the love and accolades of many other fans throughout Connecticut and beyond. Whether it be our gourmet seafood meals, delicious appetizers, New England Clam Chowder, ocean fresh fish, or our more exotic offerings, our fans are hooked on Atlantic Seafood. Not convinced? Read on and see what some of your friends and neighbors have had to say.

 

My family and I have had a wonderful summer made much more special by your outstanding offerings. Your fish and shellfish are always of outstanding quality and your service is beyond compare! Congrats on owning the best and the friendliest seafood market around. Although i’m not rushing the Fall, I hope you and your employees have had a wonderful summer to! P.S. The lobster sauce was excellent on pasta. Just the right flavor and consistency!

-Dale Wilcox

 

Lisa will not compromise on any item especially regarding quality and freshness. She insists on no additives or preservatives. Lisa has done a fantastic job of setting the goals of the highest bar, and then exceeding them at every turn. I feel comfortable doing quality work for a quality establishment. As a side comment, I’ve been there many times and dealt with the staff, and I can say that I can’t find a more accommodating group of people serving the public.” -Steve Lemieux, Owner, LeBest Printing

 

 

We wouldn’t buy fish anywhere else!” -Christine Cronin

Lisa has done a terrific job with this business. -Greg Rainey

The freshest fish and the ‘bestest’ service on the shoreline. Quality people with quality goods. Thank heaven they’re here!” -Eileen Breslin

 

From a fish connoisseur, by far the best fish around.” -Lynn Coville

The only place to go for the best seafood around. Always fresh and delicious. And don’t miss the fabulous salads, they’re always terrific.” -June Wadsworth

Middle-of-the-road is not the description of this place. We love it.” -Barbara Dimberg

 

Great product. Friendly staff. Innovative new market.” -Gene Creighton

Great products, wonderful staff, great assortment of food.” -Elizabeth Landry

Outstanding Market. Made our town better.” -Frank Landrey

From classes, to answering specific questions on food prep, to always having the freshest seafood & having a great system for holiday order pick-ups. They are the best worth a trip from anywhere.” -Janeen Carabetta

 

 

This is a fabulous fish and other store. I wish I didn’t live so far away.” -Judy Wiley

Superb fish! Chef belongs at the Pavillion Cover work at Bobby Flays. Spectacular sevice, Managment auspicious, friendly and caring.” -Augie Capaccio

Best fish in the whole area!! Friendly, wonderful service!! Also–BEST bread in town for french toast!” -Barbara Stack

Not only is the seafood fresh and delicious but staff is so kind and helpful especially to my vista members and staff.” -Celia V.

 

Always courteous, always the freshest product.” -Steve Dudley

Wonderful service. Great, fresh seafood. A pleasure to visit store!” -Susan & Bill Bucham

Lobster bake was wonderful! Everything was very fresh and delicious.” -Maureen Nelson

Informative, courteous, kind. Wonderful presentation of foods. Great hours.” -Jodie G.

Service with a smile–always! Great, delicious seafood!” -Maria Cusano

 

For four consecutive years, we’ve been Zagat rated we’ve also been voted Shoreline Business of the Year by the Old Saybrook Chamber of Commerce.

The New York Times has also recognized our efforts in providing the best seafood in Connecticut. Here’s just some of what they had to say:

“YOU won’t find the world’s largest selection of fish at Atlantic Seafood, but it does carry just about everything required for an old fashioned clambake — except the sandpit and logs for a fire. To find fish any fresher, you’d probably have to throw out a line and catch them yourself.”